Funny, Smart and No

Here’s things that I bet upper level improv teachers/coaches would be uncomfortable to say:

  • “Being funny is good in improv!”
  • “Characters should feel comfortable saying no!”
  • “You should know a lot of things if you want to be a good improviser!”

But all of these things are true.

(NOT for beginning improvisers. These sentences would be destructive in a level one improv class). 

I believe that people will read that list and interpret them like this:

  • “Make jokes that are off topic and that decrease your emotional commitment!”
  • “Stop forward action and reject your partner’s offers in order to be funny!”
  • “Make references for their own sake!”

That is not what I was saying.

Go ahead, define “funny” “smart” and “no” in a context that paints them as dangerous improv advice — it’s easy to do. 

OR: realize that we get scared of those words and that it limits our improv. Yet those words are an essential part of compelling comedy and theater.

I’m interested in a discussion on this, although I don’t need you to tell me how people can use the words “funny” “smart” and “no” dangerously.

I need ways to use those terms well. At the advanced level, it is often what is missing.

This is one in a series of me trying to figure out the proper way to teach “no.”

  1. markdavidchristenson reblogged this from dco1
  2. queennubian reblogged this from poupak
  3. poupak reblogged this from shortbreadsh and added:
    There are some really interesting discussions going on around a couple of Will Hines’ posts about improv that you can...
  4. halphillips reblogged this from improvnonsense and added:
    think what really matters...understand why. If you understand why “no” is usually bad,...
  5. improv-is-easy reblogged this from dco1 and added:
    This is great, too!
  6. improv-is-easy reblogged this from chrisreblogs and added:
    Chris nails it. (Also, a good teacher should never make their students feel dumb.)
  7. chrisreblogs reblogged this from improvnonsense and added:
    Semantics are tricky....am reminded of taking my first UCB 401. On the second day, the...
  8. dco1 reblogged this from improvnonsense and added:
    don’t think I have any authority...writing this, but I am an improv nerd, so I am writing...
  9. ferniecommaalex reblogged this from improvnonsense and added:
    This is a good post (despite being from Will Hines, an avowed enemy of mine.) There are lots and lots and lots of...
  10. shortbreadsh reblogged this from improvnonsense and added:
    don’t have a dog...this fight but since your “know everything” post still annoys me a year...
Short URL for this post: http://tmblr.co/ZuvjMyE9U0lh